We are at a defining moment in workforce development. For decades, the college degree was an unchallenged gold standard — an easy filter, a presumed predictor of success. While that credential serves a purpose, the modern hiring and talent economy demands something more powerful: validated, demonstrable skills.
The skills-based hiring movement is no longer a buzzword, but a strategic business advantage.
74% of employers say they are struggling to find the skilled talent they need, and with no sign of the talent crisis ending, HR can no longer afford to operate with outdated filters. It’s simple: relying solely on college diplomas limits your candidate pool and limits innovation.
The shift to skills-based hiring changes more than just your job descriptions; it redefines how we build teams, drive innovation, and compete in the talent market. This guide walks you through a practical, step-by-step framework for skills-based hiring, including how to ditch the arbitrary degree filter, vet candidate experience accurately, and build a trustworthy process necessary for the skills economy.
Skills-based hiring is not as complex as it may seem. Essentially, it’s a simple HR strategy that hires based on what a candidate can prove they can do, instead of where they went to school. Skills-based hiring shifts the focus from credentials to competencies and capabilities.
Relying on college degrees may seem like a convenient way to screen candidates, but it can actually create unnecessary barriers to hiring. Treating a diploma as a proxy for skills saves time, but actively reduces your talent pool, limits innovation, and prevents you from hiring top candidates.
Your current hiring filters are likely rejecting highly qualified candidates. Consider this the cost of missing non-traditional talent — or the massive pool of proven expertise gained outside the traditional university track. But what kind of candidates could you actually be missing out on?
Traditional vetting methods, like education verification, only tell you where someone studied, not how well they will perform. A college degree offers a baseline, but it’s not necessarily a predictor of day-to-day job performance. Skills-based hiring can help reduce the risk of unfit hires by ensuring every new hire has the competencies required to succeed in the role.
Relying on a degree can be a fast track to hiring bias. It inherently favors candidates with access and funds for traditional schooling. Vetting candidates beyond the degree filter is a practical step HR departments can take to boost diversity and foster a more equitable, inclusive hiring process.
Moving to a skills-based hiring model requires updating your candidate vetting process. Your goal should be to replace the degree filter with a structured, objective process that measures proven skills and abilities. Here’s what that looks like in action:
The first step in implementing skills-based hiring is establishing what your organization needs, including an accurate baseline for every role. The best place to start is with a deep audit of what certain roles actually require to be successful.
Once you’ve defined the hard skills and competencies required, you need to identify reliable and objective methods to vet candidates. These targeted assessment methods are some of the most effective predictors of future job performance:
| Assessment Method | Focus | Why It Works |
| Work Sample Tests | Hard Skills: coding challenges, design mock-ups, writing samples, etc | Directly evaluates a candidate’s ability to perform core job functions |
| Scenario-Based Interviews | Problem-Solving: questions related to specific job scenarios, i.e., “here is a common project failure point - how would you triage it?” | Assesses critical thinking and technical decision-making under realistic pressure |
| Behavioral Interviews | Competencies: consider using the STAR method to gauge adaptability, leadership, and teamwork | Uncovers necessary soft skills and cultural fit by exploring past actions |
You’re probably thinking, “But if I don’t check a degree, how can I trust a candidate’s self-reported experience (i.e., job titles, employment dates, claimed responsibilities)?”
You’re smart to ask that. This is exactly where the risk lies in skills-based hiring, and why verification is a non-negotiable practice.
Relying on simple calls or internal HR checks is not sufficient for the complexity of non-traditional résumés. Since skills can be self-taught or earned outside of structured employment, you need a dedicated, compliant process to validate a candidate’s claims.
The shift to a skills-first approach changes your compliance and verification responsibilities. Since you are validating skills rather than degrees, the process must focus on confirming the integrity of a candidate’s professional experience. This is where a dedicated screening partner becomes essential.
Your background screening solution should help verify and validate the professional experience and qualifications a candidate claims they learned:
A skill is a measurable ability or knowledge, such as Python coding, specific accounting software capabilities, or Salesforce proficiency. A competency is a soft skill, or an underlying behavior or trait that enables success. Competencies can include adaptability, critical thinking, leadership, or teamwork. Skills-based hiring requires evaluating both skills and competencies.
Yes, absolutely. Without the degree filter, you are heavily relying on self-reported experience. Background screening validates a candidate's criminal history, but can also help validate experience by confirming professional timelines, job titles, past-employment dates, and references. This ensures that your hires are safe, compliant, and equipped with the skills necessary for the role.
Focus the conversation on measurable business outcomes. Demonstrate skills-based hiring leads to better quality of hire, reduced time to fill due to a wider talent pool, and improved employee retention since assessment methods target a more strategic, long-term fit.
This entirely depends on the role and the specific skills or competencies required. While work-sample tests (such as coding challenges or design projects) are often the most statistically predictive for hard skills, complex roles require a mix. For soft skills such as leadership and collaboration, behavioral and scenario-based interviews are essential. The best strategy is a tailored toolkit, not a single test.
Yes, and often more defensible. When assessments are based solely on job-related skills and are uniformly applied across all candidates, they are less likely to lead to disparate impact than subjective degree requirements. The key is ensuring your assessment methods (like work-sample tests) are validated, consistent, and directly relevant to the essential functions of the job.
Skills-based hiring is more than just an HR trend. By embracing skills-based hiring, you stop missing out on highly qualified candidates, gain immediate access to a wider talent pool, and secure the quality of hire needed to drive innovation.
However, this strategic shift requires a new level of diligence. That’s where Verified First can help. We offer comprehensive background check packages tailored to your organization’s unique needs. We stand alongside you to support hiring efforts, offering industry-leading turnaround times and competitive pricing where you only pay for what you need.
Verified First can support your skills-based hiring model through a full suite of comprehensive services, including:
Looking for support in your skills-based hiring efforts?
We are proud members of the Professional Background Screening Association (PBSA)
Verified First is NIST 800-53 compliant.
© 2025 Verified First, LLC | Privacy Policy | Legal
