“Hmmm. Did that candidate ever get back to me?”
“Whoa—looks like we saw a ton of new applications come in yesterday. There’s no way I can respond to them all today!”
“Ugh, I keep getting ignored when I reach out to schedule an interview. What’s going on?”
Every recruiter has probably had thoughts like these before. On the surface, they might seem unrelated, but they all point to the same issue: an inconsistent talent pipeline.
When candidate flow is unpredictable, it creates more stress, more follow-up, and more friction. But with the right candidate nurture strategy in place, you can build a talent pipeline that’s steady, manageable, and aligned with your long-term hiring goals. A truly sustainable pipeline delivers a consistent flow of candidates while ensuring you have the insights needed to confidently bring the right people onto your team.
In this blog, we’ll walk through three practical steps to create a more sustainable pipeline, plus the tools that can help you stay people-first while keeping the process moving. Let’s get into it!
Before you engage candidates, get clear on what “great” actually looks like for each role. When you define must-have skills, preferred experiences, and standout qualities upfront, you help your team avoid chasing mismatched candidates. This can also help make your outreach and sourcing efforts more focused and efficient.
Your candidate relationship management should reinforce this clarity. Highlight the traits you’re looking for, and tailor your messaging to show how a candidate aligns with your ideal candidate profile. This kind of precision builds stronger connections and improves time-to-hire.
Building a strong foundation also includes considering the importance of a safe and trustworthy work environment. Defining 'great' can extend beyond skills and experience to encompass the integrity and reliability you seek in your team members. This is why establishing processes for thorough candidate vetting, including background screening, is a crucial element of a sustainable and secure hiring strategy.
Once you’ve settled on what you’re looking for, the last thing you want is a surge of initial interest followed by silence. Leveraging features like Lever's candidate nurture tools allows you to create tailored campaigns for individuals or candidate groups, ensuring the conversation remains relevant and valuable.
Stay timely with your nurture messages by setting up emails or texts to automatically send based on a predefined schedule or a specific trigger, like an action recipients take. Using automation in this way means you can keep candidates engaged and excited without a whole lot of manual effort, giving you a more even and reliable talent pipeline in the long run.
And don’t just send timely responses in your nurture messages; send personal ones. How did they come in? Are they a referral? Have they expressed interest in an open role with you before? Make sure to include unique details so candidates feel welcomed, seen, and excited to work with you. Maintaining this consistent and personalized communication ensures a smooth flow of information, which becomes increasingly important throughout the hiring process.
By now, you understand how a steady nurture cadence can help you keep candidates engaged. But what you might not know is that it can also be a great way to communicate timelines to candidates. This kind of expectation-setting can be really key when it comes to preventing talent drop-off or ghosting.
Employ's 2025 Job Seeker Nation Report found that a communicative, timely hiring experience is the best way to make a positive impression on talent. Look for opportunities in your candidate nurture journey to set expectations about the hiring process and proactively answer questions such as:
Leveraging your talent-nurturing strategy to set these expectations is also why it’s so important to use the right channel to reach out to talent. Nurture strategies work best when they’re not one-size-fits-all, which means email may not be the most convenient way for all candidates to stay engaged. Try candidate texting with applicants who indicate a preference for it, and reap the benefits in the form of a more tuned-in and sustainable pipeline of talent.
As you communicate timelines with candidates, your talent-nurture strategy can also help you gather key information and avoid delays, especially when time is of the essence. Be sure to set expectations around any steps that require quick action, like verifications. Communicating the timeline and requirements for background checks early in the process helps ensure a smoother experience for both your team and the candidate.
That’s where Verified First comes in. Our solution integrates directly with recruiting solutions such as Lever, helping busy teams manage critical hiring steps, like background checks, drug testing, and verifications, without the back-and-forth.
This integration ensures a smoother candidate experience by minimizing delays and reducing the administrative burden on your team. The result? Less manual follow-up, smoother candidate movement, and built-in compliance from start to finish. By addressing potential bottlenecks efficiently, you can maintain the momentum you've built through effective engagement and clear communication, strengthening your talent pipeline.
With all the moving pieces in successful recruiting, it’s understandable for even seasoned recruiters to sometimes feel overwhelmed. As so many companies try to do more with less, recruiters need ways to streamline their workloads while still consistently finding the right fit and making it stick.
By implementing these key steps and leveraging the right solutions, you can build and maintain a talent pipeline that operates efficiently and effectively, all while prioritizing the human element of recruitment. Discover how the combined power of Lever and Verified First can simplify your processes, empower you to achieve your hiring objectives with greater confidence, and ultimately contribute to the success of your entire organization by bringing in the right people, the right way.
We are proud members of the Professional Background Screening Association (PBSA)
Verified First is NIST 800-53 compliant.
© 2025 Verified First, LLC | Privacy Policy | Legal
