Verified First Blog

You Think You Don't Test? Your Hiring Process Already Does

Subscribe to Our Blog

By Mike Callen, President, TestGenius

About the author: Mike Callen is President of TestGenius, a pre-employment testing platform from Biddle Consulting Group, and co-host of the podcast Testing, Testing 1-2-3. This post is adapted from the episode "So, You Don't Test? A Closer Look at Why You Should." It's for general information and isn't legal advice.

Pre-employment testing graphic: “You Think You Don’t Test? Your Hiring Process Already Does” with insight from TestGenius and Verified First

Our team attends about forty-five conferences and trade shows a year, and one exchange happens more often than I can believe. An HR manager or recruiter walks past our booth, reads the word "testing" on the backdrop, and says, "Oh, we don't do that." Sometimes they add that they've been told they can't test, that it's risky, or even that it's illegal.

Here’s the reality. If your organization reviews resumes, conducts interviews, or decides which applicants move forward in the hiring process, you're already testing. You just might not call it that.

And that's an important distinction, because avoiding formal assessments doesn't necessarily eliminate the risks associated with hiring decisions. In some cases, it may actually make those decisions harder to explain or defend. 

If it screens people out, it's a test

In 1971, the U.S. Supreme Court decided Griggs v. Duke Power. When Title VII of the Civil Rights Act took effect in July 1965, Duke Power began requiring employees who wanted to advance into its better-paying departments to pass two general aptitude tests, on top of a high school diploma requirement it already had. None of these requirements had been shown to relate to doing those jobs, and both screened out black workers at far higher rates than white workers.

The court ruled that practices, procedures, or tests (PPTs) can't stand if they aren't related to the job. Legally, a “test” isn't only a traditional test. It's any step that advances some applicants and not others.

Look at how many of those PPTs are already in a typical hiring process:

  • The job posting. Imagine a posting that says the job requires lifting 50-pound bags of concrete, when the safety team switched to 25-pound bags last year. You've just screened people out over a requirement that no longer exists.
  • The job application. Every question is a filter. Asking for a diploma on a job that doesn't need one (the very issue in Griggs), or asking how far someone lives from the office, can screen out protected groups without anyone intending it.
  • The phone screening and the interview. Some people advance, and some don't. That's a test, and often the most subjective one in the process.
  • Background and credit checks. Some candidates clear them, and some don't. More on this below.
  • Physical ability tests, post-offer medical exams, psychological screening, and training academies. Not every job uses these, but where they're used, each one is a test.

Nearly every employer uses at least three of these: a posting, an application, and an interview. So, the real question isn't whether you test; it's whether each step is job-related and consistent with business necessity, and whether you could verify that if someone asked.

Background checks are tests, too

A background check has people who pass and people who don't (based on the company’s criteria), so the same principles apply.

Apply them consistently. If you run checks on entry-level armed guards, run the same checks on the supervisors who carry the same responsibilities. People vying for the same role should go through the same process. This is no argument for screening less, it's an argument for screening in a way that's consistent, job-related, and documented. That's the same standard every other step in your process should meet.

Give me five minutes and I can know if you will succeed or not

Much of our work is with 911 and emergency dispatch centers. Over the years, many center directors have told me the same thing: "I can sit down with someone for five or ten minutes and know whether they'll make it on the job."

I believe them. They've been doing this a long time, and they know the work. But picture it from the applicant's side. They sat down, had a short conversation, and were told they're not a fit. But, there's no paper trail to explain why the decision was made. 

The best of those directors finish the story like this: "But I don't do it that way." They don't want to spend their time interviewing people who lack the basic skills. So, they test first, and they save the interview (and background check, polygraph, psych eval, etc.) for candidates who have already shown they can do the core work.

What objective testing adds

A process applicants accept. If I take an Excel test for an office job and I struggle, I may be disappointed, but I'm not going to blame the employer. I know how well I did or didn’t do. Every organization recruits from its own community, customers, or market, and today any unhappy applicant will share their experiences online. You'll never please everyone, but a process that feels fair and job-related earns you the 99 good reviews that outweigh the one bad one.

A paper trail. Testing creates documentation at the step that often screens out the most applicants. That's exactly where you want your strongest records. When a client has told us a test is being challenged, our advice has been to send the validation report to the other side. More often than not, that ends the conversation. 

"We don't have the time or money to test"

One of our reps, Nick Brown, puts it simply at conferences. He asks whether anyone has hired a person whose resume listed “Excel experience”, only to watch them type numbers into cells and add them up on a calculator. Everyone laughs, and then everyone nods. You want to find that out before the offer, not after.

A quick audit you can run this month

Whether or not you use formal tests today, you can start here:

  • Review each job posting for accuracy, especially physical requirements, schedules, and qualifications, and have someone sign off.
  • Read your application with fresh eyes and remove any question you can't tie to the job.
  • Pull your applicant tracking data and compare pass rates by group at each step, from posting to offer.
  • Make sure interviews are structured, with the same questions and rating approach for every candidate in a role.
  • Confirm background and credit checks are applied consistently by role and meet the fair-chance and credit-check rules where you hire.
  • Keep records of each of these reviews. That's your part of your audit trail.

So, you say you don't test?

Look again. Every step that determines who moves forward is part of your selection process, whether you call it a test or not. The goal should be to make better, more informed hiring decisions through practices that are job-related, consistently applied, and supported by evidence. Because the real risk isn't necessarily that you're testing candidates. It's that you may already be testing them without realizing it, or without being able to explain why.

📋

Better Hiring Decisions, From Skills to Screening

Skills tests and background checks are both part of your selection process. Both work best when they’re job-related, applied consistently, and well documented. That’s why Verified First partners with TestGenius. TestGenius shows you how candidates actually perform, using assessments that mirror real work. Verified First provides accurate, compliant background screening through customizable packages and seamless integrations. Used together, they help you make more informed, defensible hiring decisions. Learn more about the Verified First and TestGenius partnership.
October 27, 2026 by Verified First
About Verified First
Verified First offers a streamlined screening experience. With robust screening solutions, including background checks, drug testing, I-9 & E-verify, and more, you can effortlessly evaluate candidates, recruit volunteers, and rescreen employees. Our patented screening technology seamlessly and securely connects with 150+ cloud-based people and volunteer management platforms. We offer no annual commitments, long-term contracts, or minimum screening requirements. And the best part? We have an industry-leading, PBSA-accredited client care team to support you along the way.
Table of Contents
Primary Item (H2)
Ready to Solve Your Biggest Screening Challenges?
Get Started
READ NEXT
×
×
×

Ready to Solve Your Biggest Screening Challenges?

Connect with a Verified First consultant for a personalized audit of your current background screening process.
linkedin facebook pinterest youtube rss twitter instagram facebook-blank rss-blank linkedin-blank pinterest youtube twitter instagram